Best Milkshakes in NYC 2024

• #1

  Lexington Candy Shop

  1226 Lexington Ave
• #2

  5 Napkin Burger — Hell's Kitchen

  630 9th Avenue
• #3

  5 Napkin Burger — Upper West Side

  2315 Broadway
• #4

  Shake Shack

  366 Columbus Ave
• #5

  Bill's Bar & Burger — Rockefeller Center

  16 West 51st Street
• #6

  Shake Shack

  Madison Square Park (West 23rd Street & Madison Ave.)
• #7

  Steak 'n Shake

  1695 Broadway
• #8

  Big Gay Ice Cream Shop

  125 East 7th Street
• #9

  Big Gay Ice Cream Shop — Greenwich Village

  61 Grove Street